Penn's practice isn't open to the media until Tuesday, so the only football we're going to get until then is Redskins-Eagles and some good old Monday-morning quarterbacking.
I take the opposite view as Josh below. I thought the safety was pretty cool in the heat of the moment but a couple of days later I'm seeing the folly of it, for two reasons.
It's much easier to get into field goal range than it is to actually punch through a touchdown, even accounting for the extra distance. Or, put differently, the closer you get to the end zone, the harder it is to gain yards. This principle was on display all game; Penn's defense never let anyone near the end zone all day but let Lafayette into "deep" field goal range at least two or three times. (I think the Leopards went for it twice from 4th-and-medium, and missed one kick.)
The seeds of the game-winning drive were sown by a couple of quarterback runs (one designed, one improvised, I think). Those kinds of plays are very possible in the open field but they wouldn't have worked inside the 10 or so -- the defense probably would have been packed in too tightly.
Give Lafayette a first-and-10 from the 25, and I don't think they score a touchdown. But with a first-and-10 from the 50, they have a puncher's chance of moving the ball 25-30 yards. The actual distance is the same but the last few yards are so much harder to get in the first situation.
Making them score a touchdown has the added advantage of getting the ball back with some time left on the clock. With a field goal, Lafayette can (and did) time it so that the game would basically be over after the attempt. But you can't choose when you score a touchdown. So even when Lafayette does get a TD, Penn has an excellent chance of getting the ball back with at least a minute to go, since there were five minutes left in the game at the time of the decision.
I can't fault coach Bagnoli too much, though. After sitting through a day of NFL football yesterday -- the league in which most coaches would punt from midfield on 4th-and-short down 14 points in the fourth quarter -- it was nice to see someone show some guts.
